HOW A HOLOGRAPHIC WILL CAN LEAD TO LITIGATION

By Peter Strobis

October 12, 2023

In season four of Succession, Logan Roy, the patriarch of the family and acting CEO of Waystar Royco, suddenly passes away amid a corporate merger. The majority ownership of the company was divided amongst the Roy Family, in what appears to be a series of highly sophisticated estate and tax planning strategies, resulting in the family members having significant power over the management of the company.

After Logan’s death, a typed document is found in his safe that may or may not be Logan’s Last Will and Testament. The document contained “testamentary intent,” that appears to express the desire that Logan’s son, Kendall Logan Roy, be appointed as the next CEO of Waystar Royco. Throughout the first four seasons, Kendall struggled with substance abuse, mental health issues, and poor decision-making leading many to believe that Logan may have begun looking outside the Roy Family for his successor.

When the Will is found, the characters immediately point out that Logan, or someone else, attempted to edit the terms of the document by making handwritten notes and either underlining or striking through the name “Kendall Logan Roy.” Did Logan underline Kendall’s name to confirm his commitment to his son, or did Logan determine that Kendall was ultimately unfit for the role?
When a Will is handwritten, either completely or partially, and not witnessed or notarized, the document is generally considered to be a “holographic will.” In Florida, a handwritten will is only valid if executed in the presence of two witnesses. Importantly, if a testator in Florida attempts to make handwritten changes to the their will, the handwritten amendments will likely not be honored by the Probate Court.

It is important to know that the laws differ from state to state. In New York, for example, a holographic will – even if no witnesses are present – can be validly admitted to Probate if it can be proven that the amendments are in the testator’s handwriting and that the testator intended for the writing to be incorporated in the Will. While in Florida, the Courts will likely not entertain any arguments to admit an unwitnessed last will and testament, barring extreme circumstances.

It is striking that Logan Roy, who undoubtedly hired top attorneys to parcel Waystar Royco’s ownership between the family, still relied on a handwritten note to govern the succession of his multi-billion-dollar conglomerate. It just goes to show that these scenarios can, and do, happen. If you wish to make changes to your will, trust, or corporate governance, it is critical to consult an estate planning attorney licensed in the jurisdiction of your current residence.

Recent Posts

HOW TO BUY ULTRA-DANGEROUS ASSETS

It’s never a good idea to buy an asset, like a boat or plane, in your own name or to have multiple parties on the title. First of all, when your name is on the title, you are personally liable for any damage that the asset may cause. For example, you and Joe own a...

SO, YOU WANT TO WRESTLE AN ALLIGATOR?

Before base jumping into the miasma of risk, the first thing you should do is make sure your estate plan, in its current iteration, meets your needs and has adapted to any challenging or changing family situation. A well-rounded estate plan is literally more of a life...

HASTE MAKES WASTE . . . CASH THE CHECK.

One never knows what corner the grim reaper lies behind. A final illness can often accelerate quickly and deprive a donor of adequate time to complete gifts for tax purposes that he intended to make. In a recent federal court case, the Third Circuit Court of Appeals...