Non-compete agreements (“NCAs”) are a key component in virtually all merger and acquisition transactions and, provided they are reasonably in scope and duration, they have generally been enforced by the courts in cases involving post-closing challenges. It is quite common that NCAs include both the selling company and its owners, as well as key employees of the business being acquired.
The primary reason for enforcing NCAs is to ensure that the buyer gets the benefit of its bargain. Clearly, no one would pay a seller the value of its business if the seller could open a competing business across the street after the closing.
While this seems straightforward as it relates to the seller and its owners, since they share in the proceeds of the sale, the common inclusion of key employees in these NCAs raises at least two issues. First, how can key employees who do not share in the sale proceeds be incentivized to agree to these new restrictions? Secondly, how does the proliferation of recent state laws limiting NCAs in the context of employees who are not selling their businesses impact key employees of the company being sold?
What Law Applies
In most M&A transactions, the parties join in an asset purchase agreement, stock purchase agreement or merger agreement, depending on the structure of the transaction (an “Acquisition Agreement”). The Acquisition Agreement will refer to a number of ancillary agreements, which usually are attached as exhibits, the signing of which will be a condition to the closing. The Acquisition Agreement will usually state that it is governed by the laws of a particular state, typically the laws of the state where the buyer is organized or where its principal place of business is located. The NCA of the seller and its owners is often included in the Acquisition Agreement or in a separate NCA among those parties. Conversely, since the buyer wants to be sure that it will acquire the services of certain key employees after the closing, the key employees will typically be required to sign a separate employment agreement, which will include its NCA obligations vis-a-vis the buyer. Under the laws of many states, in order to be enforceable against the employee, that agreement must be governed by the laws of the state where most of the services will be rendered and that is often different from the state whose laws govern the Acquisition Agreement.
Recent Trends in State Employment Laws
California has long had employment laws that favor employees, including limitations on employee NCAs. In recent years, this trend toward pro-employee employment laws has been adopted by a significant number of other states, including Rhode Island and Massachusetts. These newer NCA laws include mandatory notice provisions to give employees an opportunity to seek legal advice before signing and restrictions on the duration of employee NCAs. In some cases, there is a requirement that the employee be paid for any period the NCA remains in effect after he or she is no longer employed by the company.
Some Practical Considerations
In light of the foregoing, buyers may be ill-advised to require that new employment agreements be governed by the laws of the state where the buyer is organized or headquartered if key employees will be rendering substantial services in another state.
Sellers should recognize that the refusal of one or more key employees to agree to employment terms with the new buyer could jeopardize the closing of the proposed transaction. In negotiating the Acquisition Agreement, we typically advise sellers to take the position that key employees do not share in the sale proceeds so their agreeing to employment and NCA terms with the buyer cannot be a condition to closing of the transaction with the seller. Where the buyer will not agree, sellers should be prepared to consider paying economic incentives to its key employees provided that they agree to stay with the seller through closing and accept reasonable employment terms with the new owner of the business.
If you have questions about NCAs or any other business matter, please contact PLDO Partner William F. Miller at 508-420-7159 or email [email protected].
